Download FND app Android Aapp IoS App
FND Links Feedback Donate Language
Home / FAQ / Can people with FND have changes to the structure of their brain too?

Can people with FND have changes to the structure of their brain too?

FND means functional neurological disorder. It describes a problem with the function of the nervous system – a software problem rather than a hardware problem. In recent years though several studies have suggested that people with FND may have some changes to the structure of their brain too. Is this correct? And if so what does it mean for how we think about FND?

There have been several interesting studies of differences in brain structure between FND and healthy controls. In one study Carine Maurer in the US and colleagues compared brain scans of 48 people with FND movement disorders with 55 healthy controls of the same age and gender1.

They found that there were some areas of the brain, in the ‘Gray’ matter that were smaller in patients with FND than healthy controls. These were particularly in areas of the brain related to movement and sensation and areas that are important in experiencing emotions and ‘fight or flight’ responses.

Several other studies have shown somewhat different findings. I was a co-author on a paper led by David Perez and Indrit Begue, that summarised those findings2. A consistent pattern hasn’t emerged but it seems likely that there are differences, at a group level between patients who have FND and healthy individuals.

Areas in the brain that may change in FND

Why didn’t my MRI scan show these structural changes?

The changes being reported are all subtle and at a group level, so needs the pooling of the scans of lots of individuals to find a discernible difference. The approach taken to investigate these potential brain changes are using research methods that are not validated for clinical use and the clinical significance of these findings remains poorly understood. Furthermore, they are not detectable on individual brain scans which are typically normal in FND, unless the person has another neurological condition or an incidental finding (those are common occurring in 1 in 6 of the population)3

Why are the brains of people with FND structurally different?

We don’t know. It could be that people with FND are born with differently structured brains that make them susceptible to the condition.

Our brains are constantly changing, developing and shrinking throughout our life. It’s a bit like a muscle. If you use a certain part a lot then it will get bigger, if you don’t it may shrink. For example, London Taxi Drivers who had to learn all the streets of London by heart, have a larger ‘navigational’ area of the brain than people who are not taxi drivers1.

In fact, people with most psychiatric disorders, such as depression, anxiety and PTSD, have also been found to have structural changes in their brain too, and to a degree that is similar to the studies in FND.

The structural ‘hardware’ changes may be important because these findings might promote the vulnerability in the system to frequent ‘software crashes’. The structural alterations being generally found in cortical and limbic areas that are communicating with sensorimotor pathways.

Another possibility is that people with FND develop changes in the structure of the brain as a consequence of having the condition, rather than a cause of the condition. That certainly happens in other neurological conditions.

It seems likely that the answer will lie somewhere in between. There probably are structural vulnerabilities and the condition probably changes the brain too.

So do these studies show that it should now be classified as a purely neurological disorder?

FND has a really difficult and stigmatised history. For a very long time it was classified as a purely psychological disorder. In the last 20 years we have been uncovering some of the ways in which FND symptoms are caused in the brain, and have made a lot of progress, but we are still a long way from a definite model.

All of this shakes up our preconceived ideas about what a neurological disorder is and what a psychiatric disorder is. It turns out that the division is false and all of them are occurring in the brain.

But it shouldn’t be called FND anymore right?

The name Functional Neurological Disorder describes a condition in which there is a disorder of nervous system functioning. It’s called that in large part because of the way that it is diagnosed. For example:

All of these common clinical features clearly show there is a problem with function which is much more obvious than a subtle problem with structure. If it was the structure then the weakness would not transiently improve, the tremor would not transiently stop, and the gait would not improve.

From a practical point of view, understanding what these clinical features mean can really help people with FND to see that there is a potential for recovery, that their situation and symptoms may not be as irreversible as they may first appear.

The physiotherapy and psychological therapies being developed for FND help people to get their heads round these issues and build on them for treatment to help ‘retrain the brain’.

In physiotherapy, if someone’s walking can improve when they are going fast, the physio may use that to regain more normal ‘automatic’ walking patterns. In psychological therapy, understanding more about how weird the brain is, and how working too hard to make a movement actually make its worse, and more so if you get frustrated or worried, can help.

Many people with FND can’t improve, even when they understand the condition and are really motivated to change. Perhaps the structural changes we have found, or the changes in brain function are too difficult to overcome. We just don’t know at this point whether that is the case or not.

Shouldn’t doctors spend more time explaining these structural changes with patients?

Most people with FND think, at some point, that there must be some damage to their brain to cause the symptoms they have.

Understanding how symptoms can transiently improve and how rehabilitation therapies can build on then to gradually gain greater improvement is a key part of clinical treatment. These new FND treatments have already been shown to be promising in randomised controlled clinical trials.

We may at some stage need to build in an understanding of these structural changes into our models and the way we explain FND. But at the moment we simply don’t have enough data to be able to use this information in a clinically useful way.

If the structural changes have always been there, then that’s clearly important but we still don’t know if they represent an obstacle to improvement.

If the structural changes happen because of the condition, then we need to help patients understand that FND has changed their brain, but treatment can hopefully change it back again.

References

  1. Maurer CW, LaFaver K, Limachia GS, et al. Gray matter differences in patients with functional movement disorders. Neurology 2018; 91: e1870–9
  2. Bègue I, Adams C, Stone J, Perez DL. Structural alterations in functional neurological disorder and related conditions: a software and hardware problem? NeuroImage Clin 2019; 22: 101798.
  3. Morris Z, Whiteley WN, Longstreth Jr. WT, et al. Incidental findings on brain magnetic resonance imaging: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ 2009; 339: b3016.
  4. Woollett K, Maguire EA. Acquiring “the Knowledge” of London’s Layout Drives Structural Brain Changes. Curr Biol 2011; 21: 2109–14.

best ed pills non prescription do sex enhancement pills work male ultracore side effects pills for penis grow best fast acting male enhancement pills testosterone pills black market increase erection naturally top 10 male enhancement products beyond human testosterone booster blue sex pills 8000mg sex drive pills walmart walgreens erectile dysfunction virmax maximum male enhancement does clenbuterol increase testosterone ed drugs comparison how to enlarge your penis pills extreme endurance side effects best over the counter male enhancement products consumer reports testosterone boosters male low libido symptoms embova rx male enhancement does nolvadex increase testosterone erectile dysfunction best drugs pros and cons of penis growth pills male libido xl amazon does testosterone booster work male enhancement pills zenerx herbal supplements for sex drive what male enhancement pill works right away fda banned male enhancement pills how to make your penis longer eithout pills guaranteed to get you hard birth control pills and testosterone levels the best viagra alternative

how much cbd oil to take for cancer acl cbd oil cbd oil fda approval hemp oil omega ratio chia cbd oil same day cbd oil can you use cbd oil with xanax hemp seed oil herpes cbd oil bitcoin cbd oil north dakota vitality extracts cbd oil cbd oil and plaquenil where can i buy charlottes web cbd oil in colorado how long does the effects of cbd oil last cbd oil vs smoking weed reddit hemp cbd oil laws cbd oil for healing after surgery cbd oil charlottes web coupon nus cbd oil how many drops of cbd oil should i take for severe rls the best strains for cbd oil how much does occ cbd oil cost nutrapure cbd oil dosing cbd oil for anxiety how fast does cbd oil work for depression feals cbd oil ratings what store carries cbd oil cbd oil iowa law premium cbd oil grape is there any bad things about taking cbd oil does cbd oil have thc and can i fail a drug test cbd oil order online for pajistan cbd oil lazarus natural cbd oil vs hemp oil effects

ashley graham weight loss premier protein weight loss reviews healthy cereal for weight loss healthy low fat recipes for weight loss how to lose weight after cesarean section new ace diet pills reviews mens weight loss workout routine ebay weight loss pills weight loss prescription dr gs keto diet female meal plan weight loss in cats with good appetite best celebrity diet pills weight loss dayton injectable weight loss dr gs work out plans to lose weight visi weight loss pill keto diet cabbage prescription weight loss pills for sale amazon diet pills appetite suppressant weight loss pills speed up metabolism gluten free weight loss pills smoking cigarettes to lose weight diet pills recommended by dr oz core power yoga weight loss white diet pills with blue specks is keto a healthy diet carb limit on keto diet weight loss cleanses at home adr nalize weight loss pills fastin xr diet pills for sale insulin diet pills cardio to lose weight in 2 weeks pepperoni on keto diet purple dr gon diet pills

home window repair surprise az cost of sash windows replacement home window repair near buda tx window chip repair price window crank repair nfrc ratings replacement windows window replacements for home reviews of replacement windows different types of replacement windows front door side windows replacement do it yourself replacement windows window repair friendswood tx compare replacement windows for homes window replacement new haven replace exterior window sill andersen window installation instructions north georgia replacement windows window glass repair okc replacement windows denver co replacement windows winston salem nc windows replacement nj aluminum double pane window replacement louisville window replacement grant for energy efficient windows window replacement grants available pella window repair parts inside window sill replacement gas company window replacement program casement window replacement crank handle windows replacement salem glass replacement for doors front window screen replacement window repair avon in window chip repair denver